The Cost of GreatSchools


School Rating Systems

The theory behind GreatSchools and Niche is a good one. As parents, we all want our kids to have a great education, and having a rating system makes it easy for us to see if their school is a good one. The problem is, theories often don't work in real practice. With school rating systems, the issue is that school factors only constitute 20% of what goes into achievement test results. What that means is that it is impossible to quantify the quality of instruction and school setting by looking primarily at testing data. Don't believe me? Read this article:


How does this affect real estate?

Schools are a big factor in home values. I've had a million conversations with people about what they look for in a new home and, if a couple has children, school quality is always near the top of the list.



"Honey, I absolutely LOVE the kitchen! And the yard is perfect for the kids to play in!"
"What's the GreatSchools rating of the neighborhood school?"
"Ooh, it's only a 4. What a shame... the house is fantastic."

This conversation happens over and over, so homes located in school zones with high GreatSchools ratings are in high demand... driving up prices in these areas. Yes, the kids at these schools have success on their standardized tests. The thing is, their academic success has more to do with their economic privilege than the school itself. Again, read that article I linked earlier for proof. This isn't to say that privilege is wrong, or that schools with high ratings on GreatSchools are bad. It's just that it takes more than a GreatSchools rating to determine how good a school is.

This weekend, one of the homes I'm visiting is in Cameron Station, on the west end of Alexandria City. The neighborhood school (Samuel Tucker Elementary) is rated only a '4' on GreatSchools, but I know the community and school. I've seen phenomenal instructional practices. I've watched the diverse student body play together on the playground. The kids at the school THRIVE. But, the cost of a home in the Tucker school zone is still reasonable.

All this is to say that, when on the hunt for your perfect home, don't eliminate it based on the GreatSchools rating. If you love a house located in a school zone that has a low rating, do some legwork on the school. Not only might you be pleasantly surprised, but you might find the house is much less expensive than a comparable on located in the neighborhood with a great school rating.





Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Modeling Homes and Model Homes

Open House Report: I Dare (Ct.) You!

Factors in this Real Estate Boom